By Howard Freeman, Senior Consultant & Director of Research
Key Takeaways
- Your next major donor is likely already in your database—not a new prospect you haven’t met yet.
- The strongest signal may not be gift size; look for consistency instead.
- Standard wealth-screening tools often undervalue donors whose wealth sits in private businesses or partnerships rather than real estate.
- Your team can complete the included five-step plan in a few hours this week.
Do you lie awake at 2:00 a.m. with a racing mind, working out every possible avenue that could lead to the gift that endows that scholarship, funds that new worship center, or launches that new program?
Here’s the truth: the transformational partner you’re searching for is often already in your backyard (read: your CRM). When you move from viewing supporters as transactional donors to engaging them as true partners, you are on your way to unlocking extraordinary capacity.
Borrowing the metaphor from Russell Conwell’s famous speech “Acres of Diamonds,” we are presented with a timeless truth: the best donor is a current donor.
The first principle of our Taking Donors SeriouslyⓇ fundraising system is that “People give to people they know and trust.” That’s the reason the transformational gift you’re looking for may be hidden in plain sight, waiting to be discovered among the authentic relationships you already have.
Which of these donors might give your next transformational gift?
Below are fictional profiles of five typical financial supporters you might have met through your ministry. Give yourself two minutes and pick the one you think is most likely to make a transformational gift.
- Margaret W. has a lifetime giving of $340,000, which makes her your largest lifetime donor. She gave $100,000 three years ago and nothing since. She’s 81. Your last two calls went to voicemail, and she hasn’t called back.
- Ray T. has given $1,200 each year since 2007. He comes to the banquet every year, sits near the back, and leaves early. He owns a regional HVAC company with about sixty employees. Wealth screening estimates his net worth at $1.5M. There’s a note in his file from 2024: Ray asked after the banquet whether we’d ever thought about a second location.
- The Kims gave a one-time gift of $50,000 after the banquet two years ago. No giving before that, nothing since. They didn’t respond to the acknowledgment letter, but wealth screening indicates they own several properties, including a vacation home in Maui, and have a net worth exceeding $20M.
- Dr. Ellis gives $5,000 a year. He’s an orthopedic surgeon and a colleague of one of your board members. He opens every email you send, and last December he forwarded your year-end newsletter to a list of forty people.
- Tom and Sherri gave appreciated stock in 2023 and again in 2024. Last December, a $25,000 grant arrived from their donor-advised fund. Their giving has grown every year for six years.
Got your answer?
And the diamond in your backyard is…
The single most important fact above: 19 unbroken years of giving $1,200. Every. Single. Year. The fourth TDS principle is that “Giving is a way of life,” and it most certainly is for Ray. He has been giving at—yet not above—the level he’s been invited to. He is waiting to be asked and shown how to make a larger impact (that’s principle #2). Some people have the gift of generosity (Romans 12:8), and Ray has been exercising his gift faithfully in front of you for almost two decades.
His capacity is real but nearly invisible.
Most screening tools anchor their analysis on residential real estate ownership and the income assumed to support it. They undervalue privately held businesses, farmland, and closely held partnerships, which is exactly where a man with sixty employees keeps his wealth.
And then there’s the file note. In 2024, unprompted, Ray asked whether you’d ever thought about a second location. People give when they’re involved and have a sense of ownership (principle #3). Ray signaled where his heart was two years ago, offering to partner more significantly with your vision, but no one invited him further in.
Tom and Sherri are the sleeper. The gift of appreciated stock plus a donor-advised fund tells you they have both liquidity and philanthropic sophistication, and six straight years of growth tells you their hearts are moving toward you. They belong on your short list.
What to do this week
Here’s what you or someone on your team can do this week over the course of a few hours.
- Pull your loyalty list. Gather a list of everyone who has given five or more years in a row, regardless of amount, but is current within the last 13 months. For most organizations, that list is short enough to pray over by name.
- Read one file all the way through. Pick the name that surprises you most and start there. Don’t read just the summary screen. Look at each of their gifts, the timing, and any messages that were exchanged.
- Ask a different question. Instead of asking how much this person could give, ask how you can build real trust and involve them. How can you move them closer to true ownership of the vision? As a first step, that might mean inviting them to come see your work.
- Go visit, with no ask. Be up front when you schedule it. “This coffee is not about asking you for a gift.” Then keep your word. Ask what first drew them in and what they’d love to see your organization doing that you currently aren’t.
- Later, show them how. Most faithful givers have never been asked whether they’d consider giving something other than cash (e.g., an appreciated asset, real estate, or including your organization in their estate plan).
Your organization’s next partner who could make that transformational gift is probably not a stranger. They’ve given faithfully because giving is a way of life for them—and they are just waiting for you to involve them in your bigger vision.
So, instead of losing sleep, take a fresh look at the partners God has already brought to your ministry. Continue to move deeper into relationship with them, and you will be amazed at the diamonds you might discover. Right there, in your own backyard.
About the Author

We’ve been privileged to help many organizations be more effective in their fundraising by learning and implementing relational fundraising principles in their work with donors. Want to talk?